Published in "Eukaryotic Gene Regulation", Volume 1, pp. 131-143, 1980, edit. Kolodny GM, CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, USA. 

"Selective Gene De-Repression by De-Repressor RNA."

John H. Frenster, M.D., Department of Medicine, Stanford University, Stanford, California 94305, USA. 


1. Introduction

2. Gene De-Repression
a. Heterochromatin and Euchromatin
b. Selective Transcription
c. DNA Helix Openings

3. De-Repressor RNA
a. Assays of Gene De-Repression
b. Isolation and Characterization
c. Interaction with DNA and RNA
     Fig. 1: Gene-Specific Feedback Control of Gene De-repression.

4. Mechanisms of Action
     Fig. 2: Interactions between DNA, De-repressor RNA and Immediate Transcription-product RNA.

5. Addendum
6. Summary
7. References

8. Additional References for RNA as a Therapeutic Agent:
9. Links to Other Sites:
10. Information and Feedback:




1. Introduction:

Recent experiments utilizing endogenous RNA polymerase (1) have confirmed earlier studies (2-4) which indicated that certain species of low molecular weight RNA can function as de-repressors of gene transcription within higher organisms. Such gene de-repression results in the synthesis of messenger RNA molecules which are characteristic of the particular cells studied (5) and which may account for the positive effects of added nuclear RNA during embryogenesis (6, 7), bacterial (8) or fungal (9) transformation, and the immune response (10). These species of nuclear RNA have been variously referred to as de-repressor RNA (11), chromosomal RNA (3, 4), or activator RNA (12), and are thought to constitute the effector molecules of those complex control systems in higher organisms in which the product of one gene can specifically increase the activity of other genes in the same (12) or adjoining cells (13-15).

Gene regulation in lower organisms, especially bacteria, is mediated largely by protein molecules acting as repressors or inducers of gene activity (16). In these prokaryote organisms, criteria of fitness involve maximum growth when the environment permits it, and minimum growth when the environment demands it. By contrast, in higher organisms the internal environment of the organism is more stable, and criteria of fitness involve restraint of growth in a balanced manner and specialization of function of each cell. Although some protein mechanisms for gene regulation are retained in higher organisms, it is not surprising that the special needs for balanced growth and specialized function in higher organisms should also utilize the higher degree of gene selectivity offered by RNA molecules.

Regulation of gene activity in a positve mechanism by de-repressor RNA provides a unique informational system that maximizes :
1. selectivity for particular gene loci;
2. localization and stability within the cell nucleus;
3. transmission at the time of cell division to the daughter nuclei; and
4. stability within cell nuclei through many cell generations,
all of which reflect the long-term stability of cell differentiation in higher organisms.

2. Gene De-repression:

a. Heterochromatin and Euchromatin:

Higher organisms are composed of a myriad of tissues, each composed of cells differentiated to a specific state and function (5). Such cell differentiation is mediated by selective gene de-repression of an otherwise completely repressed genome (17), with the de-repressed genes being transcribed for specific RNA and protein synthesis characteristic of the differentiated state of that cell (18). The microscopic appearance of such differentiation in the cell nucleus (19) is revealed in the partition of interphase chromatin into at least two phase states within the nucleus:
1. large masses of condensed heterochromatin, and
2. fine microfibrils of extended euchromatin (20).

Detailed studies of the molecular biophysics, biochemistry, and ultrastucture of heterochromatin and euchromatin have revealed a striking partition of function between the two states of chromatin (Table 1), with the most significant being that all active RNA synthesis is confined to the extended euchromatin portion of the cell nucleus (21, 22). Preparative methods have been developed to fractionate the cell nucleus, allowing the physical isolation of either heterochromatin or euchromatin from one tissue sample (21), and these isolated fractions have yielded biochemical and biophysical data which have helped to elucidate the mechanism of gene de-repression (2) and selective transcription (31) within the cells of higher organisms.



Table 1. Contrast Between Heterochromatin and Euchromatin Within Animal Cells.
Heterochromatin Euchromatin Reference
Condensed masses. Extended microfibrils. 20
No RNA synthesis. Active RNA synthesis. 21, 22
Late DNA replication. Early DNA replication. 21, 23
No DNA helix openings. Many DNA helix openings. 24, 25
Few nuclear polyanions. Many nuclear polyanions. 2
Histones tightly bound to DNA. Histones loosely bound to DNA. 2
Many nucleosomes. Few nucleosomes. 19
Little steroid hormone binding. Much steroid hormone binding. 26
Little oncogenic virus binding. Much oncogenic virus binding. 27
Little chemical carcinogen binding. Much chemical carcinogen binding. 28
Much PHA mitogen binding. Little PHA mitogen binding. 29
Increased during cell differentiation. Decreased during cell differentiation. 25
Increased during cell division. Decreased during cell division. 30
Decreased during cell neoplasia. Increased during cell neoplasia. 25
Decreased during lymphocyte activation. Increased during lymphocyte activation. 30
Responsive to added de-repressor RNA. Resistant to added de-repressor RNA. 2


b. Selective Transcription:

Each normal diploid cell of an individual animal contains a full and identical complement of all DNA molecular species characterizing that animal (5, 32). Of these DNA molecules, only a fraction are transcribed to RNA molecules within any one cell or tissue (21), with such RNA products being characteristic of the particular tissue type (32, 33).

Stable epigenetic mechanisms select specific portions of the genome for transcription (34), and these mechanisms are stable through cell divisions for up to 50 generations (35). Such selective transcription involves both the choice of a particular gene locus and the choice of a particular DNA strand within the locus on which to effect RNA synthesis (31, 36). The rate of transcription at a particular gene locus appears more influenced by such factors as the local cellular environment and the occurrence of hormonal stimulation (17). Those portions of the genome not selected for gene transcription are usually found in a condensed state, manifested ultrastructurally as masses of inactive heterochromatin (20, 21, 22). When the cell is specifically activated, these masses of condensed heterochromatin may be rapidly converted to extended euchromatin active in gene transcription (30).


c. DNA Helix Openings:

The DNA helix must open in localized areas before the interior base-coded genetic information can be used for new RNA or DNA synthesis (21, 37, 38). These DNA helix openings can be visualized by a high-resolution electron microscopic technique (24, 39), which has been applied to individual cells undergoing normal cell division and differentiation (40), embryogenesis (41), and neoplasia (42, 43). These DNA helix openings are sensitive to digestion with pancreatic DNase I (18, 24) which is relatively specific for single-strand cuts in DNA (44). Such DNA helix openings are found exclusively within transcription-active euchromatin (24), and range in size from 25 to 700 nm in length, corresponding to 70 to 2000 base pairs in DNA helix length (25).

A great variety of molecules entering the cell nucleus preferentially bind to those portions of DNA molecules which are in a single-stranded state (45). The consequences of such ligand binding to single-stranded DNA are to stabilize the particular bound DNA helix openings in the open position (Table 2), thus increasing the rates of RNA synthesis within the DNA helix opening (38, 45).

Carcinogenic chemicals, oncogenic viruses, and steroid hormones all prefer to bind to such single-stranded portions of the host cell's DNA molecules (Table 2), and each of these results in an increase in the rate of RNA synthesis after such binding (38, 45). By contrast, other ligand molecules to DNA bind preferentially to DNA in the double-stranded state (Table 2), and the effect of such ligand binding is to stabilize the closed DNA helix in the inactive state, with a resultant decrease in the rate of RNA synthesis following such binding (38, 45).



Table 2. Correlation of Nuclear Ligand Binding to DNA with the Effect on RNA Synthesis.
Nuclear ligand Preferred form of DNA for binding Effect of ligand on RNA synthesis
Histones Double-stranded Decreased
Protamines Double-stranded Decreased
Lac repressor Double-stranded Decreased
Actinomycin D Double-stranded Decreased
Acridine Orange Double-stranded Decreased
Chloroquine Double-stranded Decreased
Estradiol Single-stranded Increased
Testosterone Single-stranded Increased
Methylcholanthrene Single-stranded Increased
RNA polymerase Single-stranded Increased
De-repressor RNA Single-stranded Increased
Polyoma viral DNA Single-stranded Increased

Modified from: Frenster JH, "Selective Control of DNA Helix Openings During Gene Regulation", Cancer Research, vol. 36, pp. 3394-3398 (1976).



These molecular ligands to either single-stranded DNA or to double-stranded DNA (Table 2) are the primary molecules influencing the activity of DNA within animal cells (46). Other molecules, serving as ligands in turn to the primary ligands, are able to modify the activity of the primary ligands and, thus, exert an indirect effect on DNA itself (36). These complex interactions of DNA with primary and secondary ligands within intact cells provide the molecular basis for controlling DNA helix openings and closures at particular gene loci and, thus, of controlling the rates of RNA synthesis at these loci (46).

3. De-Repressor RNA:

a. Assays of Gene De-Repression:

Assays for de-repressor activity range between two major constraints:
1. assays reflecting the biological role of the particular gene de-repression, and
2. assays reflecting the molecular uniqueness of the particular gene de-repression.
Assays relecting the biological role might best be observed in intact animals or intact cells in which the de-repressor molecule produces a specific and crucial effect. These assays are often blurred by the multiple interactions available to the de-repressor molecule in such large and complex systems.

By contrast, assays reflecting the molecular uniqueness of the particular gene de-repression might best be observed in cell-free systems of isolated nuclei, isolated chromatin, or even isolated gene loci, in which the de-repressor molecule interacts with a specific portion of the DNA genome. These assays are often blurred in cell-free systems by the lack of a characteristic biological effect reflecting the significance of the particular gene de-repression.

Some of the more recent assays for de-repressor RNA involve comparisons between nuclear RNA molecules extracted from comparable normal or neoplastic cells (1), comparisons of 5.0 S RNA with 4.5 S RNA (47), comparisons of nuclear RNA with cytoplasmic RNA (2), comparisons of nuclear RNA extracted from immunized or non-immunized subjects (10), comparisons of RNA extracted from embryonic or non-embryonic tissues (6, 48), and comparisons of RNA extracted from cells resistant or sensitive to various drugs (8, 9).

In terms of target systems as assays, cell lysates have been used as targets in assays for initiator RNA activity (49), but isolated DNA sequences have not as yet been used as targets for such assays. By contrast, isolated chromatin is the most frequently used target in assays for de-repressor RNA activity (1, 2, 3, 4, 33, 47), but these are most accurate when they employ endogenous RNA polymerase (1, 2), since exogenous RNA polymerase may copy input RNA artifactually (50).

De-repressor RNA has also been assayed using intact cells (8-10), tissue explants (6, 7, 48), or intact animals (51) as targets, but these complex systems do not permit an unequivocal assessment of the direct effect of RNA upon particular DNA sequences.

b. Isolation and Characterization:

Early studies indicated that 10 S RNA could be separated from messenger RNA after extraction from rat liver (52). Later studies have revealed that such RNA was often found in association with histones after extraction from cells (53, 54), and some of these molecules were found to be restricted to the cell nucleus (55). Chromosomal RNA was originally isolated by a quite complicated procedure (56), but more recently this has been greatly simplified (57). Current studies have indicated that de-repressor activity is found in 4.5 S RNA (47), and can be separated from an accompanying protein which displays a direct stabilizing effect on homologous RNA polymerase (1). The sedimentation and size characteristics of such de-repressor RNA suggests it may be a member of the H class of low molecular weight nuclear RNA molecules synthesized by RNA polymerase I (58).

c. Interaction with DNA and RNA:

When chromosomal RNA is hybridized to native double-stranded DNA, the hybridization is greatly favored by the presence of 5 M urea, a condition which indicates the necessity for some opening of the DNA helix before hybridization with RNA can occur (59). Chromosomal RNA has been found to hybridize to a minimum of 16% of isolated middle-repetitive DNA sequences and a minimum of 1% of isolated single-copy rat DNA (57), or a sum of 4% of total nuclear rat DNA (57). The middle-repetitive DNA sequences to which chromosomal RNA hybridizes are found to be interspersed with single-copy DNA sequences (60) in a manner in which such middle-repetitive DNA sequences are thought to function as control elements in the transcription of the adjacent single-copy DNA sequences (12, 61). In fact, the immediate transcription-product RNA consists of chromosomal RNA sequences on the 5' end of the messenger RNA molecule (60), a position also found to be occupied by double-stranded RNA sequences of the immediate transcription-product RNA (62). These data suggest that de-repressor RNA is often found in a double-stranded state (36, 46), possibly forming a duplex with operator RNA as a complementary sequence (Figure 1). Several studies have recently shown the occurrence of such double-stranded RNA molecules within animal cells (63-65). These double-stranded RNA are quite stable, and may provide the mechanism whereby de-repression can be transported through cell division (66, 67), from the maternal cell nucleus to the nuclei of the daughter cells (68, 69).




Figure 1. Gene-specific feedback control of gene de-repression.

Figure 1.

Figure 1. Gene-specific feedback control of gene de-repression. The immediate transcription-product RNA molecule consists of both repetitive and single-copy sequences (60), corresponding to operator gene (o) and structural gene (sg) sequences (12, 17, 38). Operator RNA (oRNA) is complementary in base composition to de-repressor RNA (dRNA), and is capable of forming heterometric or homometric RNA-RNA duplexes with de-repressor RNA after excessive rates of gene transcription, thereby inducing the removal of de-repressor RNA from the DNA helix opening, and providing a gene-specific mechanism for feedback inhibition of RNA synthesis.




4. Mechanisms of Action:

Since the DNA helix must open in localized areas before the interior base-coded genetic information can be used for new RNA synthesis during gene transcription (31, 38), it is possible that all of the positive effects of added de-repressor RNA are due to the effect of such RNA on promoting such DNA helix openings within particular gene loci (11).

De-repressor RNA offers several unique properties which favor its role in such a selective control mechanism (Figure 1).